← Writing + Research

Op-ed · 2024

A RIGHT TO BE FORGOTTEN

Why we crucially need a ‘right to be forgotten’ amidst the AI surge

FormatOp-ed
Published14 March 2024
RelatedResonance

An op-ed written while building a personal AI that remembers your past: wearable AI is spreading, and in the US no federal law gives people ownership of their data or a right to have it forgotten.

Overview

01

In September 2023, in Rosalind Picard’s Affective Computing class at MIT, Wazeer Zulfikar and I started LatentLife: an AI mirror that knows the details of your past, from your own uploaded memories, and helps with your most personal needs. The plan was to pair it with a wearable that would add memories automatically.

Building it, I found that in the US no federal law gives people ownership of their own data, and there is almost no protection for a right to be forgotten. Meanwhile wearables that record what their wearer sees and hears were arriving: the Humane Pin, the Rewind Pendant, Meta’s Ray-Bans, Tab. Each has a privacy statement, and nothing stops a company from ignoring it.

The question

From the essay
After building LatentLife, I am still questioning what computers should forget and what they should never have the power to remember.
Treyden Chiaravalloti, 2024

What it argues for

02

A US right-to-be-forgotten law like the one in the EU’s GDPR, with companies such as Meta required to delete personal data on request. Wearables with cameras switched off automatically in doctors’ offices, public restrooms, schools with minors and other sanctioned private places. Delete by default, as Google had recently adopted, instead of leaving people to manage what is kept. And one easy place to see everything a company holds about you.

Wearable AI could transform healthcare and help people with dementia remember. That is the tension the essay sits in: building LatentLife made us ask whether such a device would do more harm than good, and the answer it reaches is that widely used wearable AI should wait for safeguards that guarantee individual autonomy.